Imagine you need cash for a home purchase, so you ask to withdraw money from a private credit fund you've owned for a few years. The answer comes back: not right now. The fund has received more withdrawal requests than it can honor, so it is paying out only a portion, and you'll have to wait.

This year, that scenario played out for real at several large private credit funds. It's a useful reminder that private investments can offer meaningful return potential, but they come with a tradeoff many investors don't fully appreciate until the day they need their money.

Investments like private equity, private credit, and private real estate funds, often grouped together as "alternatives," are more available to individual investors than ever. That's a welcome change. But the conversation about access has moved faster than the conversation about getting out. Here's how I think about it with clients.

Start with what you need, not with the product

I'd start by questioning the word "alternative." An alternative to what, exactly? Gold has been around at least as long as stocks and bonds. Real estate is older still. These assets only came to be seen as alternatives because, for decades, most of what individual investors could buy was the stocks and bonds that brokerage firms created and sold.

The label matters because it tempts people to start with an exciting product. The better order runs the other way: first decide what you need the money to do, then pick the type of asset, then the way you'll own it, and only then the specific fund or provider.

Real estate shows why. You can own a rental property yourself, buy one with a few partners, purchase shares of a publicly traded real estate investment trust (REIT), or invest through a private fund. It's the same asset class in every case, but the risk, cost, and ability to get your money out are very different. The right choice comes down to your time horizon and how much risk you're comfortable taking.

Decide what matters most: access or taxes

Two concerns come up again and again when people consider private investments: how easily they can get their money out, and how tax-efficient the investment is. Trying to maximize both at once rarely works, because each one should take a back seat to your main goal.

If you'll need cash for a home closing or a wedding in the next few years, easy access should come first, even if that means giving up some return or some tax benefit. The reverse is also true. In a retirement account such as a 401(k), an IRA, or a cash balance plan, the tax advantages are already built in, so the question becomes how best to use that environment.

Consider a 40-year-old contributing to a 401(k). That money may not be touched for 30 years, so being able to withdraw it on any given day isn't worth much. Set your priorities first, then choose the investment that fits them.

The real risk: needing money that isn't available

Many newer private market funds, sometimes called evergreen or semi-liquid funds, have made these investments easier to buy into. These funds typically allow withdrawals only at set intervals and up to set limits, rather than any time you like. When the structure is used correctly and the investor understands it, that's a genuine opportunity.

In fact, limited access is part of how these investments aim to earn more. When a fund manager doesn't need to keep cash on hand for withdrawals, they can invest for the long term, and higher return potential can follow.

Problems start when the access you need doesn't match the access the fund provides. Sometimes the limits weren't explained clearly. Sometimes the investor didn't want to hear them. This year, as withdrawal requests overwhelmed several large private credit funds, some funds saw their values come under pressure, less because of the loans they held than because they needed to raise cash quickly. That's not a situation any investor wants to be in.

My rule for clients is simple: before you commit money to an investment you can't easily sell, assume you won't be able to touch it. Treat it as though it doesn't exist for a decade or two. Keep an eye on it, but set your expectations about access accordingly.

Questions to ask before you invest

Newer isn't always better. Novel investment structures often come with higher costs, loosely defined terms, and risks that simply haven't surfaced yet. Simpler and lower-cost is almost always a good idea. Before investing, ask:

  • How long could my money be locked up? Get a realistic answer, not just the best-case one.
  • What does it cost? Look at all fees, not just the headline management fee.
  • What does the fund actually own? Look past the packaging to the underlying assets and the reasoning behind them.
  • Is there a simpler way to get similar exposure? Sometimes a publicly traded option does most of the job with more flexibility.

What would help: plain-English lockup terms

The change I'd most like to see in the industry is a standard disclosure form, signed by every investor, that says plainly: this money likely cannot be accessed for five, 10, 15, or 20 years, and the higher return potential is your compensation for that wait.

That kind of clarity helps everyone. Investors know exactly what they're signing up for. And fund managers can invest with confidence that a sudden rush for the exits won't force them to sell assets at bad prices, which hurts every investor who stays.

Until that becomes standard, you can ask for the same clarity yourself. If you can't get a straight answer about when you can get your money back, that's an answer in itself.

Wondering whether private investments make sense for your plan, or whether the ones you already own fit your timeline? Contact our team. We're happy to walk through it with you.

 


You may also like

Subscribe to our blog live-chat-down-arrow